Don't go there, Mr. President!


Just My Opinion Add comments

  • Font Size
  • Make Text Smaller
  • Make Text Larger

"I should say at the outset that Skip Gates is a friend, and I may be a little biased here. I don't know all the facts." – President Barack Obama responding to a reporter's question at Wednesday's primetime news conference.

***

I was hoping that President Obama would ignore the bait, that he‘d brush aside the question about Henry Lewis Gates’ now-infamous arrest.

Going there, I thought, was a no-win trap. Besides, with so many global issues resting on his Oval Office desk, it’s simply not presidential to get caught up in a low-level pissing match, especially when you concede not knowing all the facts.

But Obama did respond, and he gave his honest opinion.

And guess what: I have to agree; the Cambridge police did act “stupidly” in hauling Gates to jail.

I say that, for the purposes of this blog, assuming that every word in the police report is true, that Gates did became loud and petulant, that his did call the investigating officer a racist, that he did say "You don't know who you're messing with."

Truth is, a man who has committed no crime, standing in his own home, can legally say just about anything he darn well pleases, short of actually threatening the officer.

Still, as I said in my earlier blog, I suspect Skip Gates doesn’t have entirely clean hands in this unfortunate mess, which has now become a referendum on race relations in America.

As a writer asked on the Guardian Web site: “Why was a brilliant 58-year-old scholar unable to talk down a less educated cop trying to do his difficult job in the scholar's own home?”

(Again, read my earlier blog.)

For possible clues, look no further than a recent interview Gates gave to his daughter, Elizabeth, which was published on The Daily Beast.

Said Gates: “My house. I mean, he was there investigating? He should have gotten out of there and said, ‘I’m sorry, sir, good luck. Loved your PBS series—check with you later!’ If he would have given me his card I would have sent him a DVD!”

Assuming his daughter's quote is accurate, it seems that part of the insult for Gates may have stemmed from the fact that this intrusive white cop didn't immediately recognize him – and accord him due deference.

Only two people know for sure what happened inside Skip Gates’ Cambridge home that day, and their accounts differ wildly. So in a racially charged case of he-said-cop-said, please, Mr. President, leave the uninformed speculation to barbershop debaters and bloggers like me.

I need your presidential laser focused on health care.

Other Ways to Share

Discussions and Submission Agreement

Report Abusive/Inappropriate Comments

User Comments (5 Responses)
posted by
ts

Jul 23, 2009 at 9:51 AM

Thank you MR. PRESIDENT!!!! I just watched his press conference in which he responded to the Gates' incident; and for ONCE, he BOLDLY stood up for all of the MINORITIES who have been racially profiled by law enforcement. Considering he has not been in office a full term; I feel he is making great strides with the GARBAGE left on the front lawn left by the former president. Sure, there are many issues he has to address; but I felt it was only RIGHT of him to address this particular issue since the question was asked. In other words; DO NOT GET IT TWISTED PEOPLE HE IS A BLACK MAN TOO; AND HE IS NOT IMMUNE TO THE PREJUDICE/INJUSTICE THAT PLAGUES OUR PEOPLE.

Personally, I have a problem with some who try to tell others how to do their job; especially when they are not OUTSTANDING in theirs. There are many local issues that need to be addressed and if each person would do their share to volunteer/donate resources/mentor/cleanup our neighborhoods - this world would be a better place. Don't criticize President Obama or Mr. Gates for that matter; IF YOU ARE NOT DOING YOUR VERY BEST to help your OWN!!!!!

posted by
Mike

Jul 23, 2009 at 12:45 PM

It wasn't all that presidential, and Gates didn't come off all that professorial. As far as a referendum on the state of race relations, I thought Pat Buchanan's statements to Rachel Maddow were more telling than the incident between a cop who over-reached and a black professor with a huge ego.

posted by
Eric S.

Jul 23, 2009 at 3:07 PM

Actually the President should have avoided the question until all the facts of the incident was brought forward. We all know that racism is alive and well from all races. It is not just a Black and White issue. We all need to overcome obstacles that are in our way to become a better people. We all have a tendacy to profile a group of people regardless of the color, but do we allow negative stereotypes to influence how we should treat one another. This situation from the media can get out of control and could have the potential to cause more problems than trying to solve problems. What would Dr Martin Luther King say in this matter? Would he be truly pleased with the outcome that he sacrificed his life for? If I remember correctly he spoke for EQUALITY for ALL PEOPLE! Are we looking for Justice or to GET EVEN?!?! Hmmm...

posted by
Charles

Jul 25, 2009 at 9:33 PM

The president can't comment on things of this nature. He was not there, he does not know what happened and no matter what he said the media was going to take it and run with it. Hopefully he has learned his lesson. He is the president and there are some things he has to stay away from.
His staff failed in their duties to make sure he understood that no matter his response he was going to made out to be the bad guy and that's exactly what happened.

posted by
AJ

Jul 26, 2009 at 4:28 PM

Let's not forget the anecdotal evidence of how police walk away from some irate white men and white women without arresting them. I know many who have witnessed it on tv or in person and think boy if that were a black man or woman talking like that to an officer (black or white officer), etc. I believe the majority of police are following correct protocols no matter what color you are.
Interesting, it seemed okay per the press for President Obama to chastise the black community to get serious about education and community safety, but it's not okay for him to comment on the over reaction by police in some instances toward citizens? I think all people want to have the police on their side. Police officers don't be so stubborn and unforgiving - remember we've come a long way in building trust in our communities in Charlotte and all over urban America.

Leave a Reply





On The Web

Happy birthday J. Dilla
A tribute to the late, great hip-hop producer responsible for some of the art form's greatest sounds.

Another insult for Michelle?
Republican Mike O'Neal reportedly forwarded an email making fun of the first lady's looks.

Qcity Jobs Search
Eg. Nurse

Los Angeles, CA



  
Charlotte Jobs by Category