Feeling bad about doing good


On Faith , Around the Qcity Add comments

  • Font Size
  • Make Text Smaller
  • Make Text Larger

I think I was conned.

It happened around lunchtime in uptown Charlotte.

While rushing to a five-minute meeting in the Wachovia atrium, I noticed a woman who appeared to be crying. She was sitting on one of the many benches that line Tryon Street.

At first I kept walking, mildly curious, a wee bit sad, but determined to make my appointment.

But after traveling a few feet, each step grew progressively harder.

What obligations do we have to our fellow human beings, I asked myself. Would Jesus walk past a weeping woman invisible in a noontime crowd? I thought of the Good Samaritan, the news accounts of people who watch and do nothing while an innocent victim is raped or beaten or killed.

So around I turned.

The woman told me she was “living out here on the street” and was supposed to meet someone who had promised to buy her food. But the person was late by two hours, she said.

I explained that I had a quick meeting but promised to return in five minutes.

Only in hindsight did I note the absence of visible tears.

I kept my appointment and returned, as promised, in five minutes. The woman saw me coming and rose from the bench before I arrived.

“What do you have a taste for?” I asked.

She gave the name of a Chinese restaurant in Latta Arcade.

Again, hindsight.

It probably should have struck me as odd that a homeless person would know the name of a tucked-away eatery, but I was too busy asking questions to do the mental calculations. I wanted to know her story.

She said she had cancer. She said she had two half-sisters who told her they didn’t care if she lived or died. She said she suspected it was because she was the darkest of the three. She said the local homeless shelters had no empty beds because they gave preference to women with children. She said she had been denied disability but would appeal the ruling.

When we reached the restaurant it became apparent that this woman knew the menu better than most people know their kitchen pantries. It also became clear that the woman behind the food counter had a passing familiarity with my lunch guest.

Clearly, I was not her first chump.

All in all, I spent a grand $8 to buy this woman lunch – certainly not enough to lose sleep over.

But it did get me to thinking?

What are our obligations in a world full of trickery and deceit?

If I went back to that bench today, would I find her still there, weeping?

And because of her, will I be less likely to extend generosity the next time I encounter a person in need?

Sadly, probably so.

 

Other Ways to Share

Discussions and Submission Agreement

Report Abusive/Inappropriate Comments

User Comments (5 Responses)
posted by
Lashawnda

Jul 8, 2010 at 8:24 AM

Awww, poor thing. I've gotten burned too by people pretending to be homeless. Don't turn your back.....just be on the lookout for invisible tears.

posted by
sandra

Jul 8, 2010 at 11:03 AM

A sucker is born every minute. Editor in Chief is one.
Buying her lunch did not do anything long term for the lady, just a quick fix and I will be gone. Made you feel better for the moment

Jesus would have given her something to last a life time. Could she have done something for her meal. (lawful)

posted by
Kevin

Jul 9, 2010 at 9:30 AM

Plausibly, it was not the meal at all that was so very important to this young woman. Maybe it was your invested interest and time that was more important to her. Just for her to be able to express herself freely to someone that cared enough to inquire. Probably worth more than any meal to her.

posted by
Interested Reader

Jul 9, 2010 at 2:59 PM

Basically, you were a chump. The bottom line is that and most other street cons are easy to spot.

The one thing you have to give Charlotte credit for is feeding the homeless/hungry. Next time, give your money to the organizations and people who feed. In Jesus' day, they didn't have such services. No excuse for it now.

posted by
Cheryl

Jul 11, 2010 at 4:37 AM

You did the right thing. You reached out to help someone and so your deed is done and you are totally out of it. If she was lying then she will have to account for that. Keep following your heart and you will get your blessings. Sometimes people block their blessings when they spend so much time trying to see if someone is trying to use them. We are our brother's keeper and will be judged on it.

Leave a Reply





On The Web

Happy birthday J. Dilla
A tribute to the late, great hip-hop producer responsible for some of the art form's greatest sounds.

Another insult for Michelle?
Republican Mike O'Neal reportedly forwarded an email making fun of the first lady's looks.

Qcity Jobs Search
Eg. Nurse

Los Angeles, CA



  
Charlotte Jobs by Category