Unhealthy debate: Part I


Politics Add comments

  • Font Size
  • Make Text Smaller
  • Make Text Larger

You’ll never guess what I did last night.

I went to one of Republican Rep. Sue Myrick’s town hall meetings on health care.

Having read so much about these boisterous events, I wanted to see what all the fuss was about.

I wanted to confirm the mob outrage I'd seen on TV. I wanted to hear the barely veiled racist remarks reported to be common at other such events. I wanted to decide for myself whether these people are, as they say, simply concerned citizens, or something worse.

I also went determined to keep an open mind.

The meeting was held at 7 p.m. inside the Gaston Day School, 2001 Gaston Day School Road, Gastonia. Even by the standards of Gaston County, this was no easy drive for someone leaving Charlotte.

Myrick’s other two town hall meetings were in equally remote locations – one at Weddington High School in Union County and another at J.V. Washam Elementary School in Cornelius. I couldn’t help but wonder as I drove for miles along narrow, winding roads why Myrick had chosen to ignore Mecklenburg, the state’s largest and most diverse county.

When I arrived, five minutes late, the parking lot was full. So was the 540-seat auditorium. Myrick’s staff was setting up overflow chairs out in the lobby. Being a member of the press, I was given access to the main room. The heavy police presence could not be missed.

The audience inside was decidedly north of middle age. A few carried protest signs, but not many. I counted two African Americans.

Myrick was standing behind a large wooden podium on a large stage, explaining why she opposes President Obama’s efforts to reform health care: the proposals cost too much, they amount to a government takeover, might eventually rob families of choice, could lead to health care rationing…

“We really do need to find a way to solve this problem,” she said.

She then launched into some “common sense things” we as a nation could do to fix health care without a major overhaul: allow insurers to compete across state lines, create an online market where families can shop for low rates, phase out limitations for pre-existing conditions, make insurance portable, limit liability suits against doctors and hospitals…

Then came time for public comment.

“I was brought up to believe that government was for the people and by the people,” the first speaker, a middle-age woman, said right off the bat. “What happened? ...We don’t need another welfare program.”

“I don’t support this regime,” another speaker said, demanding to know why Obama has been appointing government czars who aren’t accountable to the people or Congress. He called them a “shadow government.”

One man said Obama was a “good talker” but was leading the United States toward dictatorship.

“I understand those concerns,” Myrick said.

Another woman said she was angry that Obama supporters had branded as racist those who oppose health care reform. “How dare they?” she kept repeating, “How dare they?”

For two hours I listened, one speaker after another, all praising Myrick for fighting the good fight – for her anti-abortion stand, for opposing health care reform, for supporting the military -- and all lambasting Obama as a danger, a menace or both.

Only two in the audience rose in support for health care reform, and both were booed or shouted down to various degrees. (One said she’d like to hit Myrick with a tomato, and the crowd gave her the expected response.)

To her credit, Myrick did try (unsuccessfully) to silence those who wanted to drown out dissent, reminding them that all deserved a chance to be heard. She also said emphatically that the Obama plan contained no provision for “death panels,” and that she wished the phrase could disappear from the public debate.

In the end, I heard nothing that was overtly, or covertly, racist. But that hardly mattered. This was not Obama’s crowd. They did not elect him. They do not like him. And he will not sway them, regardless of what he proposes.

Next time: The legitimate concerns I heard. Plus, what these town hall meetings really say about America.

 

Other Ways to Share

Discussions and Submission Agreement

Report Abusive/Inappropriate Comments

User Comments (8 Responses)
posted by
Laurel

Aug 28, 2009 at 4:35 PM

I noticed you there and was hoping you'd write about it. I went for the same reason you did, to see for myself, to listen. And WHAT an earful. That was the most scary hostile crowd. Xenophobia in it's ugliest form. I sat in the back, and was horrified to see people nearby raising arms in hitler fashion when President Obama's name was mentioned, to hear the sometimes muttered, sometimes shouted ugly comments. From where I sat there was indeed racism, both overt and covert.

Two more non-rightwingers spoke after you left, I was one of them. I didn't go to the event intending at all to speak, but something snapped in me and I needed to stand up against all the ugliness I was witnessing. I was brief, it was frightening standing there in front of that crowd. I identified myself as a small business owner and a person of faith, both of which are true, and I cringe to see that they have become code-words for conservative bigotry. In addition to explaining that I view my position supporting universal healthcare as one of morality I called the crowd out on their hostility and rudeness.

It was indeed unhealthy. It wasn't a town hall meeting, or even a debate, it was pure vitrol.

Thank you for writing about it.

posted by
Greg Flewelling

Aug 29, 2009 at 3:58 PM

There's no morality in forcing some people (50% of population that pays taxes) to pay for other people's health care.

posted by
Hal Weatherman

Aug 30, 2009 at 5:43 AM

Cornelius is in Mecklenburg County. Sue did one town hall in each county in her district (Union, Mecklenburg and Gaston). Sue's portion of Mecklenburg County is primarily South Charlotte which was easily serviced by the Weddington location. Weddington High is only a few miles off of Providence Road and 485. Hal Weatherman, office of Sue Myrick

posted by
really?

Aug 31, 2009 at 11:20 AM

really, greg? No Medicare or Social Security for you, then?

posted by
Greg Flewelling

Aug 31, 2009 at 12:09 PM

Govt. programs like Social Sec. should be for only the most needy. They have turned us into a country dependent on govt. I would love to have Social Security and Medicare taxes reduced because I can put that money into savings and get back more than I put in.

posted by
Ed

Aug 31, 2009 at 5:16 PM

I love comments like Greg's. Roads, universities, public schools, community colleges, mass transit: all supported by public money. Those without cars pay for roads and those with cars pay for bus service but it's all too much when the for profit health industry may lose some profit. Ridiculous.

posted by
Greg Flewelling

Aug 31, 2009 at 11:33 PM

Has nothing to do with health insurance companies. It's a philosophical and ideological perspective. I favor returning all the services you mentioned to the private sector.

posted by
Eric S.

Sep 16, 2009 at 8:05 AM

Has anyone ever figured out how we are going to pay for this Healthcare reform? There is a cost associated with this reform. It is not free and it will cost me more to pay for my coverage than what I am paying now. Under this Healthcare reform, I will pay almost double for my heath insurance, because I will not recieve any medical or tax credits that would lower the cost for my family coverage. From what I have heard and what I am reading, this Healthcare reform like any other Gov't program (Social Security, wellfare) will be break us because of all the new tax increases. Look at our school system ...sales tax increase to pay for teachers and the sin tax. What is going to happen when less people stop purchasing cigarettes and alcohol, but the budget is dependant on the revenue it has collected over the years. Hmm... money has to come from another means... more taxes!!!!!!

Leave a Reply





On The Web

Ed Gordon is back on BET
Known for in depth interviews, the award-winning anchor is excited about returning to news.



  •  
  •